Remove.bg vs Aiarty Image Matting: Which One Delivers Better Background Removal?

Remove.bg vs Aiarty Image Matting: Side-by-Side Comparison

While both Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting utilize AI for background removal, they differ in features, effectiveness, and overall user experience. To help you decide which one suits your needs better, let's compare them side by side.

Background Removal Quality

Both tools use AI to remove backgrounds, but they differ significantly in precision and edge handling.

Remove.bg is ideal for simple backgrounds and well-defined subjects, offering fast processing. However, it may struggle with fine details such as wisps of hair, transparent elements, and soft edges, sometimes resulting in subject loss or jagged edges.

Aiarty Image Matting, on the other hand, excels in handling complex backgrounds, offering better edge refinement and preserving intricate details. This is made possible by Aiarty’s advanced AI models and built-in refinement options. It features four AI models tailored for different image types:

• AlphaStandard V2: Preserves translucency and edge details, making it ideal for semi-transparent objects like wedding dresses, water droplets, and hair strands.
• AlphaEdge V2: Enhances edge sharpness using deep convolutional layers, best suited for images requiring high-clarity edges.
• EdgeClear V2: Improves edge precision and detail retention, particularly effective for objects like birds, bicycles, and furniture.
• SolidMat V2: Optimized for solid objects such as books, clothing, and buildings, ensuring sharp and well-defined cutouts.

Aiarty also provides four refinement options to further improve background removal accuracy:

• Smooth Processing: Softens cutout edges for a more natural look and reduces jagged artifacts, especially effective for images above 2K resolution.
• Outline Emphasis: Enhances contour detection, making edges more prominent during the AI processing.
• Balance Brightness: Adjusts brightness detection to maintain optimal contrast and visibility.
• Invert Alpha Mask: Reverses the selected area, swapping the subject and background. This is useful for creative compositions where the original background needs to be retained.

In most cases, selecting the appropriate AI model alone ensures high-precision background removal. However, refinement options can be used to further fine-tune results. For users with extremely high accuracy demands, Aiarty also includes manual tools, which will be discussed in the next section - Manual Adjustment Options.

To see a real-world comparison of how Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting perform on different types of images, check out the Test Comparison section below.

Manual Adjustment Options

When it comes to refining background removal results, Remove.bg keeps things simple. It provides basic erase and restore tools, along with an adjustable brush and a magic brush for edge detection. These options allow for quick touch-ups but don’t offer much flexibility for handling complex details like semi-transparent objects or fine textures.

Aiarty Image Matting, on the other hand, gives users much more control. In addition to AI-powered automatic background removal, it allows manual selection for more precise edits. What sets it apart are its four specialized drawing tools:

1. Eraser – Removes unwanted areas while maintaining smooth transitions.
2. Brush – Refines transparency, letting users fine-tune how objects blend into their surroundings.
3. Dodge – Softens edges and improves depth, making the subject look more naturally integrated.
4. Burn – Enhances transparency in selected areas, useful for complex objects like smoke, glass, or hair.

These tools help users achieve a high level of detail, making Aiarty Image Matting particularly useful for e-commerce sellers, photographers, and designers who need professional-quality results.

Beyond these manual refinements, Aiarty also includes edge smoothing and brightness balancing, which further enhance the final cutout by ensuring clean, natural transitions.

If you need a quick, automated solution, Remove.bg is a solid option. But if you’re looking for more control over details and transparency, Aiarty Image Matting delivers a much more refined editing experience.

Batch Processing

For users who need to process multiple images at once, Remove.bg has some limitations. The web app does not support batch processing, meaning users have to upload and edit images one by one. While the desktop app does allow batch processing, it comes with restrictions—images must be under 50 megapixels in resolution and 22MB in size (previously 25MP and 12MB).

In contrast, Aiarty Image Matting offers a much more efficient solution for large-scale editing. It supports batch processing for up to 3,000 images at a time, with no size or resolution limits. This makes it a more practical choice for businesses, e-commerce sellers, and designers who frequently work with high volumes of images.

Background Replacement

Both Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting allow users to change the background of images, offering the option to select solid colors or upload custom backgrounds.

However, there are also some differences in their offerings.

Remove.bg provides a range of pre-made background templates, allowing users to quickly apply a stylish or context-appropriate backdrop to their images. This is particularly useful for users who want to save time and don't need a completely custom background.

Aiarty Image Matting, on the other hand, does not offer background templates but provides more flexibility with the ability to use gradient color backgrounds. This feature gives users the option to create smooth transitions between colors, adding a more dynamic look to their images.

Supported Formats

The range of supported file formats is another key difference between Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting.

Remove.bg supports only a limited set of image formats for input: JFIF, PJPEG, JPEG, PJP, JPG, and PNG. For output, it exclusively exports images in PNG format, even if the background is not transparent.

Aiarty Image Matting, in contrast, supports a much wider range of input formats, including standard image files (HEIC, JPG, JPEG, BMP, PNG, WEBP, AVIF, TIFF, JFIF, JP2, and more) as well as RAW formats from various camera brands such as Canon, Nikon, Sony, Fujifilm, Panasonic, Olympus, Pentax, Hasselblad, Phase One, Leica, Samsung, and Kodak. For output, Aiarty provides more flexibility, allowing users to export images in PNG (8-bit or 16-bit) and JPG.

If you're working with standard image formats, Remove.bg covers the basics. But for photographers and professionals dealing with RAW images, Aiarty Image Matting is the better choice due to its extensive format compatibility.

Output Resolution

A major difference between Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting lies in how they handle output resolution.

Remove.bg restricts free users to lower-resolution previews. For example, if you upload a 1920x1280 image, you can only download a 612x408 version unless you upgrade to a paid plan. High-resolution downloads are only available for paying users.

Aiarty Image Matting, on the other hand, always preserves the original resolution by default, ensuring no loss of quality. Beyond that, Aiarty includes a built-in AI enhancer, allowing users to enhance and upscale images using one of three AI models. The upscaling options include 1x and 2x, making it a valuable tool for those who want to improve image quality while removing backgrounds.

For users who need high-resolution images without restrictions, Aiarty Image Matting is the clear winner.

Bonus Features

Both Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting go beyond simple background removal by offering additional editing tools, but their capabilities differ significantly.

Remove.bg provides a couple of quick enhancements: users can blur the background with an adjustable blur amount or add a shadow to the subject for a more natural look.

Aiarty Image Matting, on the other hand, offers a much wider range of tools for fine-tuning images. It includes an AI enhancer to improve image quality, along with basic editing options like rotate, flip, and crop. For refining edges, the Feather tool helps create smoother transitions. Additionally, Aiarty allows users to blur either the background or the subject, apply a black-and-white effect to either, or even pixelate one of them for artistic or privacy reasons.

Pricing

Remove.bg follows a pay-as-you-go or subscription-based pricing model, where users must purchase credits to download high-resolution images. Free users are limited to low-resolution previews, making it less ideal for those who frequently need high-quality cutouts.

Aiarty Image Matting, on the other hand, is currently offering a limited-time promotion where you can remove backgrounds for free with a one-year license for version 2.0, which would normally cost $49. However, this version does not include free upgrades for new AI models or future software updates.

For regular pricing, Aiarty Image Matting provides two pricing options: a Standard License at $49 per year and a Lifetime License at $75 as a one-time payment. Compared to subscription-based models, the Lifetime License offers a significantly better long-term value, allowing users to access all features indefinitely with free lifetime updates. This makes Aiarty a budget-friendly choice for those who prefer a one-time purchase over recurring payments.

Test Comparison: Test Results Don't Lie

To provide a more visual comparison between Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting, we have selected three images:

1. A simple product image with an almost plain background and a well-defined outline.
2. A complex product image with intricate details and a cluttered background.
3. A portrait with many fine hair strands.

Now, let's take a look at the final comparison results.

Example 1: Simple Product Image

Original image description: This is a picture of a water bottle. It features a simple background, a straightforward object outline, and a clear contrast between the foreground and background.

Final Results Comparison:

In this particular image of the water bottle, the automatic cutout results from remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting are quite similar. Both tools successfully separated the water bottle from the background, and the bottle's outline and overall shape were well preserved. In terms of detail handling, both performed comparably, with relatively smooth edges and no noticeable jaggedness.

However, the crucial difference lies in the resolution. remove.bg significantly reduced the image's resolution. The original image was 1920x2880, while remove.bg's output was only 408x612. This means a substantial loss of image clarity and detail.

Conversely, Aiarty Image Matting maintained the original image resolution, ensuring no decrease in image quality.

Example 2: Complex Product Image

Original image description: A cool mountain bike, with a red and black color scheme, is parked on a wooden boardwalk, set against a backdrop of green forests.

Final Results Comparison:

First up, we tried remove.bg. And, you know, at first glance, it looks like it did a decent job. It cut the bike out. But when you look closer, that's where you see the problems. It really struggled with the finer details, like the spokes on the wheels, and some of the thinner parts of the bike's frame. Plus, the edges were kind of jagged. And, here's the big thing: it seriously reduced the image resolution. The original was 1920x1080, and remove.bg knocked it down to 612x408. That's a huge drop in quality.

Then, we tested Aiarty Image Matting. Aiarty did a much better job of preserving those fine details. The spokes, the gears, everything looked sharper and cleaner. The edges were smoother, too. And, importantly, Aiarty kept the original resolution. That's a massive advantage. So, you're not losing any image quality.

Example 3: Portrait with Fine Hair Details

Original image description: The original image is a woman portrait taken on a beach. From a cutout perspective, this image presents some challenges. The woman’s wavy hair has many fine strands, making it tricky for automated tools to separate it cleanly from the background. Additionally, the natural lighting and color transitions between the subject and background could make precise edge detection more difficult.

Final Results Comparison:

Remove.bg does a decent job of isolating the subject, but there are some noticeable flaws. The hair area loses fine details, with some strands being removed entirely, leaving the edges looking somewhat unnatural. Additionally, the output resolution is lower than the original, which might limit its usability for high-quality edits.

Aiarty, on the other hand, delivers a more refined cutout. It preserves significantly more hair details, keeping the soft, natural look of the original image. The edges appear smoother and more realistic. Moreover, Aiarty maintains the original resolution, ensuring better flexibility for further editing.

Aiarty outperforms Remove.bg in this comparison, especially when it comes to handling intricate details like hair.

Comparison Table: Remove.bg vs. Aiarty Image Matting

Conclusion: Which Background Removal Tool is Right for You?

Both Remove.bg and Aiarty Image Matting excel in simplicity and speed, making them accessible even for beginners. However, their strengths cater to different priorities. Here’s a refined breakdown to help you choose:

Choose Remove.bg if:

• You need instant online access without downloads—perfect for quick edits on the go.
• Your images have simple backgrounds (e.g., product shots, portraits with plain backdrops).
• You value pre-made templates for fast background replacements.
• Occasional use justifies its subscription model, despite free tier resolution limits.

Try Remove.bg>>

Choose Aiarty Image Matting if:

• You want no compromises on quality—preserving original resolution and handling both simple and complex backgrounds flawlessly.
• Free users need high-res outputs—Aiarty avoids resolution downgrades, even in its giveaway license.
• You seek flexibility: manual editing tools, RAW/HEIC support, and batch processing (up to 3,000 images).
• A one-time purchase aligns better with your budget.

Download Aiarty Image Matting to remove background from your images!

About the Author

This post was written by Brenda Peng who is a seasoned editor at Digiarty Software who loves turning ordinary photos into extraordinary works of art. With AI assistance from DeepSeek for brainstorming and drafting, the post is reviewed for accuracy by our expert Abby Poole for her expertise in this field.

Home > AI Product Image Editing > Remove.bg vs Aiarty Image Matting